The Witch is truly scary—not through jump scares or gore, but through atmosphere, psychological tension, and its exploration of primal fears1. This film, directed by Robert Eggers, is a slow burn that burrows under your skin and stays with you long after the credits roll3. It masterfully blends historical accuracy with folklore and psychological horror to create a truly unsettling experience4. Let’s delve into the specific elements that make The Witch such a chilling and effective horror film.
The Historical Context: A Puritan’s Nightmare
The Witch is set in 1630s New England, a time and place steeped in religious fervor and fear of the unknown5. The film draws heavily from actual historical accounts, diaries, and court records from the era, including those related to the Salem Witch Trials6. This historical authenticity adds a layer of realism to the film’s horror, making it feel like a glimpse into the darkest fears of the Puritan settlers7. Eggers meticulously recreated the language, costumes, and social dynamics of the period, immersing the audience in a world where the line between reality and superstition was blurred8. This creates an atmosphere of constant unease and paranoia, where any misfortune could be attributed to witchcraft9.
Adding to this sense of dread is the film’s setting on the edge of a dark and forbidding forest. Forests held a particular significance in the Puritan imagination, representing the unknown and the untamed wilderness where evil forces could dwell10. By placing the family in such a location, Eggers taps into these historical anxieties, creating a sense of isolation and vulnerability that permeates the entire film.
The Power of Atmosphere: Dread and Despair
The Witch excels at creating an atmosphere of dread and despair2. Cinematographer Jarin Blaschke uses natural lighting and a muted color palette to create a bleak and oppressive visual style11. The film is often cloaked in a suffocating darkness, pierced only by the flickering flames of candlelight, creating an atmosphere of claustrophobia and dread12. This is further enhanced by the film’s unusual aspect ratio of 1.66:1, which makes the woods appear taller and more menacing while simultaneously making the space inside the family’s farmhouse feel even more confined11.
The oppressive atmosphere is further heightened by Mark Korven’s unsettling score, which combines dissonant strings, eerie vocals, and unsettling percussion to create a constant sense of unease2. Even seemingly innocuous scenes, like a rabbit hopping through the woods, become imbued with a sense of foreboding thanks to the film’s masterful sound design2.
While the film generally avoids relying on traditional jump scares, Eggers does utilize them in a unique way. He often employs sudden, jarring sounds or images to disrupt the viewer’s comfort and heighten the sense of dread, even in moments that aren’t explicitly “scary.” 2 For example, a scene might abruptly begin with the loud thud of an axe splitting wood, or an unsettling children’s song might suddenly fill the soundtrack, creating a jarring transition that keeps the audience on edge.
The Psychology of Fear
Beyond the external threats and supernatural elements, The Witch is a film deeply rooted in psychological horror13. It masterfully plays on primal fears, paranoia, and the fear of the unknown13. The family’s isolation and their rigid religious beliefs create a breeding ground for suspicion and distrust, which is further fueled by the strange occurrences surrounding them4.
The film taps into the specific fears of the Puritan mindset, where the Devil was seen as a constant and insidious presence, lurking in the shadows and tempting individuals towards sin4. This fear of the Devil and the constant threat of eternal damnation created a pervasive sense of anxiety and paranoia, which is effectively captured in the film.
Psychological Horror: Paranoia and Madness
The Witch is not just about external threats; it’s about the psychological torment that fear and isolation can inflict13. The family at the center of the story is gradually driven to madness by their paranoia and suspicion14. The children, Caleb and the twins Mercy and Jonas, accuse each other of witchcraft, with the twins even claiming that the family goat, Black Phillip, speaks to them15. The parents’ faith is shaken, and their once-strong family unit crumbles under the weight of their anxieties1. This psychological unraveling is arguably more terrifying than any supernatural encounter15. The film explores the dark side of human nature, showing how fear and religious extremism can lead to violence and self-destruction10.
A key element of this psychological horror is the complex and fraught relationship between Katherine and Thomasin16. Katherine, consumed by grief over the loss of her baby, directs her anger and resentment towards Thomasin, accusing her of being a witch and blaming her for the family’s misfortunes16. Thomasin, in turn, struggles to understand her mother’s hostility and desperately seeks her approval, even as she becomes increasingly isolated and ostracized. This dynamic adds a layer of emotional intensity to the film, highlighting the destructive power of paranoia and the breakdown of familial bonds.
The Witch Herself: A Figure of Primal Fear
While the film builds suspense slowly, the witch herself is a truly terrifying presence17. She embodies primal fears of the unknown, of female sexuality, and of the power of nature16. Eggers draws on folklore and historical accounts of witchcraft to create a chillingly realistic portrayal of a witch who preys on the family’s vulnerabilities7. The film doesn’t shy away from depicting the witch’s cruelty, particularly in the disturbing scene where she uses the stolen baby, Samuel, to create a flying ointment6.
However, the film also suggests that the witch is not just an external threat but a manifestation of the family’s own repressed desires and fears18. Eggers has stated that he intentionally designed the film to be open to interpretation, with clues that could support both a literal depiction of witchcraft and a reading where the family succumbs to a shared psychosis brought on by their isolation and religious extremism18.
Black Phillip: The Devil in Disguise
Black Phillip, the family’s goat, is a constant source of unease throughout the film8. The children claim that he talks to them, and his presence is often associated with misfortune15. As the film progresses, it becomes clear that Black Phillip is more than just a goat; he is a manifestation of the Devil himself8. This adds another layer of horror to the film, as it suggests that evil can take many forms and can even infiltrate the seemingly mundane aspects of life7.
Audience Reactions: A Divisive Film
The Witch has been a divisive film, with some viewers finding it terrifying and others finding it slow or boring19. This is partly due to the film’s unconventional approach to horror14. It relies on atmosphere and psychological tension rather than jump scares or gore, which may not appeal to all horror fans14. Some viewers, accustomed to more conventional horror films with explicit scares and fast-paced action, may find the film’s slow burn and ambiguous ending frustrating19.
However, for those who appreciate slow-burn horror and are willing to immerse themselves in the film’s world, The Witch can be a truly unsettling and unforgettable experience1. The film’s historical authenticity, its exploration of primal fears, and its disturbing imagery can linger in the mind long after the credits roll.
Interestingly, the film has also elicited different responses from men and women. Some women have connected with the film’s portrayal of female oppression within a patriarchal society, seeing Thomasin’s final embrace of witchcraft as a form of liberation16. On the other hand, some men may have interpreted the ending as a confirmation of the dangers associated with female sexuality and independence, reinforcing the Puritanical fear of women as a source of evil21.
To further illustrate the different interpretations of the film’s ending, here’s a table summarizing the key points:
| Literal Interpretation | Figurative Interpretation |
|---|---|
| The witch is a real supernatural entity who preys on the family. | The family succumbs to a shared psychosis brought on by isolation and religious extremism. |
| Black Phillip is a literal manifestation of the Devil. | Black Phillip represents the family’s repressed desires and fears. |
| Thomasin willingly joins the coven and embraces evil. | Thomasin’s embrace of witchcraft is a desperate act of rebellion against her oppressive circumstances. |
| The film is a cautionary tale about the dangers of witchcraft and the Devil. | The film is a commentary on the destructive nature of religious extremism and the psychological toll of isolation. |
Conclusion: A Masterpiece of Folk Horror
The Witch is a masterpiece of folk horror that effectively blends historical accuracy, psychological tension, and supernatural elements to create a truly scary film13. It’s a film that gets under your skin and stays with you long after the credits roll, prompting reflection on the nature of fear, faith, and the dark side of human nature22. While it may not be for everyone, The Witch is a must-see for fans of atmospheric horror and those interested in exploring the darker side of history and folklore23.
Personally, I find The Witch to be one of the most effective horror films I’ve ever seen. Its power lies not in cheap scares or gore, but in its ability to create an atmosphere of unrelenting dread and to tap into deep-seated anxieties about faith, family, and the unknown. The film’s historical authenticity and its ambiguous ending only add to its unsettling power, leaving the viewer with a lingering sense of unease and a profound appreciation for the craft of horror filmmaking.
Works Cited
1. The Witch (2015) : r/movies – Reddit, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/xksf5i/the_witch_2015/
2. The Witch (2015) – ReWatch List, accessed February 6, 2025, https://rewatchlist.net/2021/03/03/the-witch-2015/
3. Film Review: “The Witch” — Mother Nature’s a Bitch and So am I – The Arts Fuse, accessed February 6, 2025, https://artsfuse.org/141076/fuse-film-review-the-witch-mother-natures-a-bitch-and-so-am-i/
4. An observation about The Witch (2015) (spoiler) : r/movies – Reddit, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/52rm1g/an_observation_about_the_witch_2015_spoiler/
5. The Witch (2015 film) – Wikipedia, accessed February 6, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Witch_(2015_film)
6. All The Witch’s Most WTF Moments, Explained: A Spoiler-Filled Interview With the Director, accessed February 6, 2025, https://slate.com/culture/2016/02/the-witch-director-robert-eggers-on-the-real-history-behind-the-movies-most-wtf-scenes.html
7. The Witch True Story & Salem Witch Trials Connection Explained – Screen Rant, accessed February 6, 2025, https://screenrant.com/witch-movie-true-story-salem-witch-trials-connection-explained/
8. The Witch: A New England Folktale | Nicole Gatt – U.OSU, accessed February 6, 2025, https://u.osu.edu/gatt4hseportfolio/2021/02/08/the-witch-a-new-england-folktale/
9. Colonising the Devil’s Territories: The Historicity of Providential New England Folklore in The VVitch – Revenant Journal, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.revenantjournal.com/contents/colonising-the-devils-territories-the-historicity-of-providential-new-england-folklore-in-the-vvitch/
10. Fear, Fantasy, and Forests: Imagining the World of Witchcraft using the 2015 Horror Film, ‘The Witch’ | Faculty of History, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.history.ox.ac.uk/fear-fantasy-and-forests-imagining-the-world-of-witchcraft-using-the-2015-horror-film-the-witch
11. The Witch – Production & Contact Info | IMDbPro, accessed February 6, 2025, https://pro.imdb.com/title/tt4263482/
12. “The Witch”: An Honest Review of the Freakishly Realistic Horror – – WXAV, accessed February 6, 2025, https://sxustudentmedia.com/the-witch-an-honest-review-of-the-freakishly-realistic-horror/
13. Review: ‘The Witch’ offers complex themes, frights | David A. Lynch, accessed February 6, 2025, https://dalexlynch.wordpress.com/2016/10/27/review-the-witch-offers-complex-themes-frights/
14. The Witch (2015) – User reviews – IMDb, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.imdb.com/title/tt4263482/reviews/
15. Exploring the Gothic Elements of The Witch – Dread Central, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.dreadcentral.com/editorials/153377/exploring-the-gothic-elements-of-the-witch/
16. [Editorial] Blood, Guts and Mommy Issues in The Witch (2015) – Ghouls Magazine, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.ghoulsmagazine.com/articles/blood-guts-mommy-issues-the-witch-2015
17. en.wikipedia.org, accessed February 6, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Witch_(2015_film)#:~:text=The%20Witch%20takes%20place%20in,and%20are%20ultimately%20proved%20correct.
18. 10 Things You Never Knew About The Making Of The Witch, accessed February 6, 2025, https://screenrant.com/the-witch-robert-eggers-behind-scenes-unknown-facts/
19. Critics Love the Horror Film The Witch. Why Don’t Viewers Think It’s Scary?, accessed February 6, 2025, https://slate.com/culture/2016/02/a24s-new-horror-film-the-witch-has-enchanted-critics-but-mainstream-audiences-are-another-story.html
20. The Witch isn’t an empowerment narrative and that’s why it’s great – Kill Screen, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.killscreen.com/the-witch-isnt-an-empowerment-narrative-and-thats-why-its-great/
21. The WITCH (2015) Explained – YouTube, accessed February 6, 2025, https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rmQKBBrdrA0&t=418s
22. “The Witch” Review: A Story of Inner and Outer Demons – Cinemablography, accessed February 6, 2025, http://www.cinemablography.org/blog/the-witch-review-a-story-of-inner-and-outer-demons
23. The Witch – 2015 Eggers – The Cinema Archives, accessed February 6, 2025, https://thecinemaarchives.com/2019/10/25/the-witch-2015-eggers/